/brz/remove-bazaar

====================

Centralized Workflow

====================

I- Overview

===========

This document describes a possible workflow for using Bazaar_. That of

using Bazaar_, the distributed version control system, in a centralized

manner. Bazaar_ is designed to be very flexible and allows several

different workflows, from fully decentralized to mostly centralized.  The

workflow used here is meant to ease a new user into more advanced usage of

Bazaar_, and allows them to work in a mix of centralized and decentralized

operations.

In general, this document is meant for users coming from a background of

centralized version control systems such as CVS or subversion. It is

common in work settings to have a single central server hosting the

codebase, with several people working on this codebase, keeping their work

in sync.  This workflow is also applicable to a single developer working

on several different machines.

.. _Bazaar: http://bazaar-vcs.org

II- Initial Setup

=================

These are some reasonably simple steps to setup Bazaar_ so that it works

well for you.

1- Setting User Email

---------------------

Your user identity is stored with each commit. While this doesn't have to

be accurate or unique, it will be used in log messages and

annotations, so it is better to have something real.

::  

   % bzr whoami "John Doe <jdoe@organization.com>"

2- Setting up a local Repository

--------------------------------

Bazaar_ branches generally copy the history information around with them,

which is part of how you can work in a fully decentralized manner. As an

optimization, it is possible for related branches to combine their storage

needs so that you do not need to copy around all of this history

information whenever you create a new branch.

The best way to do this is to create a `Shared Repository`_. In general,

branches will share their storage if they exist in a subdirectory of a

`Shared Repository`_.  So let's setup a `Shared Repository`_ in our home

directory, thus all branches we create underneath will share their history

storage.

::

  % bzr init-repo --trees ~

3- Setting up a remote Repository

---------------------------------

Many times you want a location where data is stored separately from where

you do your work. This workflow is required by centralized systems

(CVS/SVN).  Usually they are on separate machines, but not always. This is

actually a pretty good setup, especially in a work environment. Since it

ensures a central location where data can be backed up, and means that if

something happens to a developer's machine, no committed work has to be

lost.

So let's set up a shared location for our project on a remote machine

called ``centralhost``. Again, we will use a

`Shared Repository`_ to optimize disk usage.

::

  % bzr init-repo --no-trees sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/

You can think of this step as similar to setting up a new cvsroot, or

subversion repository.

III- Versioning an existing project

===================================

Now that we have a repository, let's create a versioned project. Most of

the time, you will already have some code that you are working with,

that you now want to version using Bazaar_. If the code was originally

in source control, there are many ways to convert the project to Bazaar_

without losing any history. However, this is outside the scope of this

document. See `Tracking Upstream`_ for some possibilities (section

"Converting and keeping history").

.. _Tracking Upstream: http://bazaar-vcs.org/TrackingUpstream

.. 

   XXX: We really need a different document for discussing conversion of a

   project. Right now TrackingUpstream is the best we have, though.

1- Developer 1: Creating the first revision

-------------------------------------------

So first, we want to create a branch in our remote Repository, where we

will want to host the project.  Let's assume we have a project named

"sigil" that we want to start versioning.

::

  % bzr init sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil

This can be thought of as the "HEAD" branch in CVS terms, or as the "trunk"

in Subversion terms. We will call this the ``dev`` branch.

I prefer working in a subdirectory of my home directory to avoid collisions with all

the other files that end up there. Also, we will want a project

directory where we can hold all of the different branches we end up

working on.

::

  % cd ~

  % mkdir work

  % cd work

  % mkdir sigil

  % cd sigil

  % bzr checkout sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil dev

  % cd dev

  % cp -ar ~/sigil/* .

  % bzr add

  % bzr commit -m "Initial import of Sigil"

In the example above, we created an empty branch (the ``/sigil`` branch)

on ``centralhost``, and then checkout out this empty branch onto our

workstation to add files from our existing project.

There are many ways to setup your working directory, but the steps above

make it easy to handle working with feature/bugfix branches. And one

of the strong points of Bazaar_ is how well it works with branches.

At this point, because you have a 'checkout' of the remote branch, any

commits you make in ``~/work/sigil/dev/`` will automatically be saved both locally,

and on ``centralhost``.

2- Developer N: Getting a working copy of the project

-----------------------------------------------------

Since the first developer did all of the work of creating the project,

all other developers would just checkout that branch. **They should

still follow** `1- Setting User Email`_ and `2- Setting up a local Repository`_.

To get a copy of the current development tree::

  % cd ~/work/sigil

  % bzr checkout sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil dev

Now that two people both have a checkout of

``sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil``, there will be times when one of

the checkouts will be out of date with the current version.

At commit time, Bazaar_ will inform the user of this and prevent them from

committing. To get up to date, use ``bzr update`` to update the

tree with the remote changes. This may require resolving conflicts, if the

same files have been modified.

IV- Developing on separate branches

===================================

So far everyone is working and committing their changes into the same

branch. This means that everyone needs to update fairly regularly and

deal with other people's changes. Also, if one person commits something

that breaks the codebase, then upon syncing, everyone will get the

problem.

Usually, it is better to do development on different branches, and then

integrate those back into the main branch, once they are stable. This is

one of the biggest changes from working with CVS/SVN. They both allow you

to work on separate branches, but their merging algorithms are fairly

weak, so it is difficult to keep things synchronized. Bazaar_ tracks

what has already been merged, and can even apply changes to files that

have been renamed.

1- Creating and working on a new branch

---------------------------------------

We want to keep our changes available for other people, even if they

aren't quite complete yet. So we will create a new public branch on

``centralhost``, and track it locally.

::

  % cd ~/work/sigil

  % bzr branch sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil \

               sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil/doodle-fixes

  % bzr checkout sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil/doodle-fixes doodle-fixes

  % cd doodle-fixes

We now have a place to make any fixes we need to ``doodle``. And we would

not interrupt people who are working on other parts of the code.  Because

we have a checkout, any commits made in the ``~/work/sigil/doodle-fixes/``

will also show up on ``centralhost``. [#nestedbranches]_ It is also

possible to have 2 developers collaborate on one of these branches, just

like they would have collaborated on the ``dev`` branch. [#cbranch]_

.. [#nestedbranches] It may look odd to have a branch in a subdirectory of

   another branch. This is just fine, and you can think of it as a

   heirarchial namespace. Where the nested branch is derived from the

   outer branch.

.. [#cbranch] When using lots of independent branches, having to retype

   the full URL all the time takes a lot of typing. We are looking into

   various methods to help with this, such as branch aliases, etc. For

   now, though, the bzrtools_ plugin provides the ``bzr cbranch`` command.

   Which is designed to take a base branch, create a new public branch,

   and create a checkout of that branch, all with much less typing.

   Configuring ``cbranch`` is outside the scope of this document, but the

   final commands look like ``bzr cbranch dev my-feature-branch``

.. _bzrtools: https://launchpad.net/products/bzrtools

2- Merging changes back

-----------------------

When it is decided that some of the changes in ``doodle-fixes`` are ready

to be merged into the main branch, simply do::

  % cd ~/work/sigil/dev

  % bzr merge ../doodle-fixes

Now the changes are available in the ``dev`` branch, but they have not

been committed yet. This is the time when you want to review the final

changes, and double check the code to make sure it compiles cleanly and

passes the test suite. The commands ``bzr status`` and ``bzr diff`` are

good tools to use here. Also, this is the time to resolve any conflicts.

Bazaar_ will prevent you from committing until you have resolved these

conflicts. That way you don't accidentally commit the conflict markers.

The command ``bzr status`` will show the conflicts along with the other

changes, or you can use ``bzr conflicts`` to just list conflicts. Use

``bzr resolve file/name`` or ``bzr resolve --all`` once conflicts have

been handled. [#resolve]_ If you have a conflict that is particularly

difficult to solve you may want to use the ``bzr remerge`` command. It

will let you try different merge algorithms, as well as let you see the

original source lines (``--show-base``).

.. [#resolve] Some systems make you resolve conflicts as part of the merge

   process. We have found that it is usually easier to resolve conflicts

   when you have the view of the entire tree, rather than just a single

   file. It gives you much more context, and also lets you run tests as

   you resolve the problems.

V- Recommended Branching

------------------------

One very common way to handle all of these branches is to give each

developer their own branch, and their own place to work in the central

location. This can be done with::

  % bzr branch sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil \

               sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil/user-a

  % bzr branch sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil \

               sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil/user-b

This gives each developer their own branch to work on. And, they can

easily create a new feature branch for themselves with just[#cbranch]_::

  % bzr branch sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil/user-a \

               sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil/user-a/feature 

  % cd ~/work/sigil

  % bzr checkout sftp://centralhost/srv/bzr/sigil/user-a/feature myfeature

VI- Glossary

============

Shared Repository

-----------------

Bazaar_ has the concept of a "Shared Repository". This is similar to the

concept of other RCS's repository. Such as in Subversion, where you have a

remote repository, which is where all of the history is stored, and

locally you don't have any history information, only a checkout of the

working tree files. Note that "Shared" in this context means shared

between branches. It *may* be shared between people, but standalone

branches can also be shared between people.

In Bazaar_ terms, a "Shared Repository" is a location where multiple

branches can **share** their revision history information. Because Bazaar_

wants to support decentralized workflows, it is possible for every branch

to maintain its own revision history information. But this is often

inefficient, since related branches share history, and they might as well

share the storage as well.

.. 

   vim: tw=74 ft=rst spell spelllang=en_us