/brz/remove-bazaar

Back-up and Restore

===================

Backing up Bazaar branches can be done in two different ways.  If an existing

filesystem-based backup scheme already exists, then it can easily be used

where the Bazaar branches reside.  Alternately, Bazaar itself can be used to

mirror the desired branches to or from another location for backup purposes.

Filesystem Backups

------------------

Bazaar transactions are atomic in the sense that the disk format is such that

it is in a valid state at any instant in time.  However, for a backup process

that takes a finite amount of time to complete, it is possible to have

inconsistencies between different on-disk structures when backing up a live

branch or repository.  (Bazaar itself manages this concurrency issue by only

*reading* those structures in a well-defined order.)  Tools such as LVM that

allow instantaneous snapshots of the contents of a disk can be used to take

filesystem backups of live Bazaar branches and repositories.

For other backup methods, it is necessary to take the branch or repository

offline while the backup is being done in order to guarantee consistency

between the various files that comprise a Bazaar branch's history.  This

requirement can be alleviated by using Bazaar as its own backup client,

since it follows an order for reading that is designed to manage concurrent

access (see the next section for details).  Depending on the different

access methods that are being used for a branch, there are different ways to

take the branch "offline".  For ``bzr+ssh://`` access, it is possible to

temporarily change the filesystem permissions to prevent write access from

any users.  For ``http://`` access, changing permissions, shutting down

the HTTP server or switching the server to a separate configuration that

disallows access are all possible ways to take a branch offline for backup.  

Finally, for direct filesystem access, it is necessary to make the branch

directories un-writable.

Because this sort of downtime can be very disruptive, we strongly encourage

using Bazaar itself as a backup client, where branches are copied and

updated using Bazaar directly.

Bazaar as its own backup

------------------------

The features that make Bazaar a good distributed version control system also

make it a good choice for backing itself up.  In particular, complete and

consistent copies of any branch can easily be obtained with the ``branch`` and

``pull`` commands.  As a result, a backup process can simply run ``brz pull``

on a copy of the main branch to fully update that copy.  If this backup

process runs periodically, then the backups will be as current as the last

time that ``pull`` was run.  (This is in addition to the fact

that revisions are immutable in Bazaar so that a prior revision of a branch is

always recoverable from that branch when the revision id is known.)

As an example, consider a separate backup server that stores backups in

``/var/backup``.  On that server, we could initially run

::

  $ cd /var/backup

  $ brz branch bzr+ssh://server.example.com/srv/bzr/trunk

  $ brz branch bzr+ssh://server.example.com/srv/bzr/feature-gui

to create the branches on the backup server.  Then, we could regularly (for

example from ``cron``) do

::

  $ cd /var/backup/trunk

  $ brz pull  # the location to pull from is remembered

  $ cd ../var/backup/feature-gui

  $ brz pull  # again, the parent location is remembered

The action of pulling from the parent for all branches in some directory is

common enough that there is a plugin to do it.

Bound Branch Backups

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

When ``brz pull`` is run regularly to keep a backup copy up to date, then it

is possible that there are new revisions in the original branch that have not

yet been pulled into the backup branch.  To alleviate this problem, we can set

the branches up so that new revisions are *pushed* to the backup rather than

periodically pulling.  One way to do this is using Bazaar's concept of bound

branches, where a commit in one branch happens only when the same commit

succeeds in the branch to which it is `bound`.  As a push-type technology, it

is set up on the server itself rather than on the backup machine.  For each

branch that should be backed up, you just need to use the ``bind`` command to

set the URL for the backup branch.  In our example, we first need to create

the branches on the backup server (we'll use ``brz push``, but we could as

easily have used ``brz branch`` from the backup server)

::

  $ cd /srv/bzr/projectx/trunk

  $ brz push bzr+ssh://backup.example.com/var/backup/trunk

  $ cd ../feature-gui

  $ brz push bzr+ssh://backup.example.com/var/backup/feature-gui

and then we need to bind the main branches to their backups

::

  $ cd ../trunk

  $ brz bind bzr+ssh://backup.example.com/var/backup/trunk

  $ cd ../feature-gui

  $ brz bind bzr+ssh://backup.example.com/var/backup/feature-gui

A branch can only be bound to a single location, so multiple backups cannot

be created using this method.  

Using the `automirror`_ plugin mentioned under `Hooks and Plugins <hooks-plugins.html>`_, one can

also make a push-type backup system that more naturally handles mutliple

backups.  Simply set the ``post_commit_mirror`` option to multiple URLs

separated by commas.  In order to backup to the backup server and a 

remote location, one could do

::

  $ cd /srv/bzr/trunk

  $ echo "post_commit_mirror=bzr+ssh://backup.example.com/var/backup/trunk,\

  bzr+ssh://offsite.example.org/projectx-corp/backup/trunk" >> .bzr/branch/branch.conf

  $ cd ../feature-gui

  $ echo "post_commit_mirror=bzr+ssh://backup.example.com/var/backup/feature-gui,\

  bzr+ssh://offsite.example.org/projectx-corp/backup/feature-gui" >> .bzr/branch/branch.conf

.. _automirror: http://launchpad.net/bzr-automirror

As for any push-type backup strategy that maintains consistency, the downside

of this method is that all of the backup commits must succeed before the

initial commit can succeed.  If there is a many mirror branches or if the bound

branch has a slow network connection, then the delay in the original commit may

be unacceptably long.  In this case, pull-type backups, or a mixed system may

be preferable.

Restoring from Backups

----------------------

Checking backup consistency

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Many a system administrator has been bitten by having a backup process,

but when it came time to restore from backups, finding out that the backups

themselves were flawed.  As such, it is important to check the quality of the

backups periodically.  In Bazaar, there are two ways to do this: using the

``brz check`` command and by simply making a new branch from the backup.  The

``brz check`` command goes through all of the revisions in a branch and checks

them for validity according to Bazaar's internal invariants.  Since it goes

through every revision, it can be quite slow for large branches.  The other

way to ensure that the backups can be restored from is to perform a test

restoration.  This means performing the restoration process in a temporary

directory.  After the restoration process, ``brz check`` may again be relevant

for testing the validity of the restored branches.  The following two sections

present two restoration recipes.

Restoring Filesystem Backups

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

There are many different backup tools with different ways of accessing the

backup data, so we can't cover them all here.  What we will say is that

restoring the contents of the ``/srv/bzr`` directory completely will restore

all branches stored there to their state at the time of the backup (see

`Filesystem Backups`_ for concerns on backing up live branches.)  For

example, if the backups were mounted at ``/mnt/backup/bzr`` then we could

restore using simply::

  $ cd /srv

  $ mv bzr bzr.old

  $ cp -r /mnt/backup/bzr bzr

Of course, to restore only a single branch from backup, it is sufficient to

copy only that branch.  Until the restored backup has been successfully used

in practice, we recommend keeping the original directory available.

Restoring Bazaar-based Backups

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

In order to restore from backup branches, we can simply branch them into the

appropriate location::

  $ cd /srv

  $ mv bzr bzr.old

  $ cd bzr

  $ brz branch bzr+ssh://backup.example.com/var/backup/trunk

  $ brz branch bzr+ssh://backup.example.com/var/backup/feature-gui

If there are multiple backups, then change the URL above to restore from the

other backups.